Burch Procedure: A Historical Perspective / Procedimento de Burch: Uma perspectiva histórica

Abstract Introduction The Burch procedure (1961) was considered the gold standard treatment for stress urinary incontinence (SUI) before the midurethral slings (MUSs) were introduced, in 2001. Objective This historical perspective of the Burch's timeline can encourage urogynecological surgeons to master the Burch technique as one of the options for surgical treatment of SUI. Search Strategy and Selection Criteria A bibliographic search was performed in the PubMed and National Library of Medicine (NIH) databases with the terms Burch colposuspension AND history AND stress urinary incontinence in the last 20 years. The original article by Burch (1961) was included. The references were read by three authors. The exclusion criterion was studies in non-English languages. Biomedical Library Special Collections were included as historical relevant search. Data Collection, Analysis and Main Results Some modifications of the technique have been made since the Burch procedure was first described. The interest in this technique has been increasing due to the negative publicity associated with vaginal synthetic mesh products. Twenty-nine relevant articles were included in the present review article, and numerous trials have compared Burch colposuspension with MUS. Conclusion This historical perspective enables the scientific community to review a standardized technique for SUI. Burch colposuspension should be considered an appropriate surgical treatment for women with SUI, and an option in urogynecological training programs worldwide.

Resumo Introdução O procedimento de Burch (1961) foi considerado o tratamento padrão ouro para a incontinência urinária de esforço (IUE) antes da introdução dos slings de uretra média (SUMs), em 2001. Objetivo Esta perspectiva histórica da linha do tempo do procedimento de Burch pode encorajar os cirurgiões uroginecológicos a dominar a técnica deste procedimento como uma das opções para o tratamento cirúrgico da IUE. Estratégia de busca e critérios de seleção A busca bibliográfica foi realizada nas bases de dados PubMed e National Library of Medicine (NIH) com os termos Burch colposuspension AND history AND stress urinary incontinence nos últimos 20 anos. O artigo original de Burch (1961) foi incluído. As referências foram analisadas por três autores com exclusão de estudos em idiomas diferentes do inglês. Coleções de bibliotecas biomédicas foram incluídas por ordem de relevância histórica. Coleta de dados, análise e principais resultados Algumas modificações de técnica foram realizadas desde que o procedimento de Burch foi inicialmente descrito. O interesse por essa técnica vem aumentando devido à publicidade negativa associada aos produtos de tela sintética vaginal. Vinte e nove artigos relevantes foramincluídos, e vários estudos compararam a colposuspensão de Burch com SUMs. Conclusão Essa perspectiva histórica possibilita à comunidade científica revisar uma técnica padronizada para a IUE. A colposuspensão de Burch pode ser considerada um tratamento cirúrgico adequado paramulheres com IUE, e uma opção emprogramas de treinamento uroginecológico em todo o mundo.

Evaluación de los resultados de la cura de incontinencia urinaria por técnica de Burch y cabestrillos suburetrales sin tensión

Objetivo: Evaluar los resultados positivos y negativos de la cirugía de incontinencia urinaria (IU) por técnica de colposuspensión de Burch y cabestrillos suburetrales sin tensión, tanto transobturatriz y tension-free vaginal tape, independientemente de las distintas mallas y tipos de agujas existentes en el mercado. Métodos: Se realizó un estudio no experimental, documental, retrospectivo, correlacional y longitudinal. La población estuvo constituida por la totalidad de pacientes con diagnóstico de incontinencia urinaria de esfuerzo, que acudieron a la consulta externa de cirugía General, Urología y Uroginecología del Hospital Dr. José Ignacio Baldó, entre enero 2002 y abril 2012. La muestra estuvo representada sólo por las pacientes que fueron sometidas a cura operatoria de IU por técnica de Burch o cabestrillos suburetrales sin tensión. Resultados: La proporción estimada de evoluciones satisfactorias con el uso de la técnica colposuspensión Burch fue de 87,9 % y con el uso de cabestrillos suburetrales sin tensión fue 97,3 %. La proporción de complicaciones transoperatorias en el caso de la técnica colposuspensión Burch alcanzó la cifra de 3,0 % y en el caso de cabestrillos suburetrales sin tensión fue de 10,8 %. La proporción de complicaciones postoperatorias en el caso de la técnica colposuspensión Burch alcanzó 33,3 % y en el caso de cabestrillos suburetrales sin tensión fue de 37,8 %. Conclusiones: No se encontraron diferencias estadísticamente significativas entre ambas técnicas quirúrgicas evaluadas en relación a proporción de evoluciones satisfactorias, complicaciones transoperatorias y postoperatorias.

Objective: To assess the positive and negative outcomes of both transobturator (TOT) and tension-free vaginal tape (TVT), regardless of the different meshes and existing types of needles on the market. Methods: A non-experimental, documentary, retrospective, correlational and longitudinal study was performed. The population was constituted by all patients diagnosed with stress urinary incontinence (SUI), who attended at General Surgery, Urology and Urogynaecology Service of the hospital Dr. Jose Ignacio Baldo, between January 2002 and April 2012. The sample was represented only by patients who underwent surgical cure of UI by Burch technique or tension-free suburethral slings. Results: The estimated proportion of satisfactory developments with the use of the Burch colposuspension technique was of 87.9% and with the use of tension-free suburethral slings was of 97,3%. The transoperative complications in Burch colposuspension technique was 3, 0 % and in tension-free suburethral slings was of 10.8%. The postoperative complications in the case of Burch colposuspension technique reached 33.3% and in the case of tension-free suburethral slings was 37.8%. Conclusions: No statistically significant differences were found between the two surgical techniques evaluated in relation to proportion of successful developments, transoperative and postoperative complications.

Cistouretropexia laparoscópica tipo Burch para el tratamiento de la incontinencia urinaria de esfuerzos: seguimiento a largo plazo / Laparoscopic Burch colposuspension for the treatment of stress urinary incontinence

Objetivos: Conocer las complicaciones, las tasas de cura subjetiva y valoración con el índice de severidad de Sandvik a largo plazo de pacientes en quienes se realizó cistouretropexia laparoscópica tipo Burch para la corrección de su incontinencia urinaria de esfuerzo (IUE). Método: Análisis descriptivo, retrospectivo. Nivel de evidencia III. Se incluyeron las pacientes con diagnóstico de IUE tipo Blaivas IIB, a quienes se les practicó Burch laparoscópico en la Clínica del Prado y Profamilia Medellín, entre los años 2003 y 2007. Las variables principales a evaluar fueron edad, tiempo quirúrgico, cura subjetiva, índice de severidad de Sandvik y complicaciones. Resultados: Se analizaron 72 pacientes con promedio de edad de 46,57 +/- 9,54 años. El tiempo promedio de seguimiento fue de 24,4 meses (rango: 9,0-55,8 meses). El tiempo quirúrgico promedio fue de 79,83 minutos (rango: 44-160 minutos). Refirieron cura subjetiva 56 pacientes (77,8 por ciento). El índice de severidad de Sandvik muestra que a largo plazo 56,9 por ciento pacientes estaban secas con remisión completa de los síntomas y el 13,8 por ciento pacientes tenían pérdidas leves. Conclusiones: El Burch laparoscópico es una opción efectiva para el manejo de la incontinencia urinaria de esfuerzo tipo Blaivas IIB. Provee tasas de curación subjetiva a largo plazo similares a otros tipos de tratamiento. Es una opción más a tener en cuenta en el manejo de la IUE, en especial aquellas pacientes con patologías asociadas que se beneficien del abordaje por laparoscopia.

Objectives: To describe the subjective cure rate, the score of the Sandvik test and the complications after laparoscopic Burch in patients with stress urinary incontinence (SUI). Methods: Prospective descriptive study. We included all patients diagnosed with SUI Blaivas type IIB, and operated on by laparoscopy in two reference institutions between 2003 and 2007. Results: We analyzed 72 patients with an average age of 46.57 +/- 9.54 years. The average follow-up was 24.4 months, with a minimum of 9 and a maximum of 55.8. The average operating time in 29 patients in which we only performed laparoscopic Burch with or without colporrhaphy was 93.7 minutes (55-180 minutes); 56 patients (77.8 percent) reported subjective cure. The Sandvik's severity index found 56.9 percent dry patients and 13.8 percent with mild losses. Conclusion: The laparoscopic management may be useful in some patients, especially those who will be carried to laparoscopy by some other indication. Subjective cure rates are similar to other types of surgery.

An unusual foreign body in the bladder 5 years after a laparoscopic burch colposuspension / 대한산부인과학회지

Stress urinary incontinence is the predominant symptom in young and middle-aged women. Stress urinary incontinence is not a life-threatening disease but can lead to discomfort, which can also limit the social and sexual activities of women. Lately TOT operation is performed in most cases of stress urinary incontinence. But Burch colposuspension had been one of successful operations for genuine stress incontinence until TOT procedure was performed. Burch colposuspension has significant morbidity such as bleeding, infection and wound hematoma, and subsequent complications including voiding difficulty, de novo detrusor instability, recurrent urinary tract infection and uterovaginal prolapse. In this case, Delayed migration of the suture and bolster after an endoscopic Burch colposuspension across tissue planes, with subsequent erosion into the bladder, is uncommon. We report an unusual complication 5 years after Burch operation. It was an intravesical foreign body granuloma caused by suture material.

Comparison of Outcomes between Burch Colposuspension with and without Concomitant Abdominal Hysterectomy

A total abdominal hysterectomy may cause a postoperative vesicourethral dysfunction due to an injury to the pelvic nerves. However, many incontinent women with benign diseases of the uterus and its adnexae have undergone a Burch colposuspension with a concomitant abdominal hysterectomy. This study was undertaken to compare the outcomes of a Burch colposuspension performed alone with that of a Burch with a concomitant abdominal hysterectomy. This study included 132 women, who, were treated for primary urinary incontinence from February 1999 to February 2002 and were diagnosed with stress urinary incontinence by means of the urodynamic test at the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology at Yonsei University Hospital. Forty-two women underwent a Burch colposuspension alone (Burch group) and 90 women underwent a Burch colposuspension with a concomitant abdominal hysterectomy (hysterectomy group). Between the Burch and hysterectomy groups, the mean age, parity, menopausal rate, Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT) rate, 1 year follow-up outcomes and postoperative complications were compared using the subjective and objective stress tests according to the retrospective chart review. The mean age (54.6 +/- 0.5 vs 58.6 +/- 9.2 years, p=0.382), parity (3.3 +/- 1.2 vs 3.6 +/- 1.7), menopausal rate (71.4 vs 77.7%), or HRT rate (23.3 vs 11.2%) of the two groups were similar. Complications related to surgery were encountered in 5 patients (11.9%) in the Burch group and in 7 patients (7.8%) in the hysterectomy group (p=0.842). One year follow-up subjective symptoms were encounterd in 2 patients in the Burch group and in 4 patients in the hysterectomy group (p=1.00). The stress test was positive in only one patient in the hysterectomy (p=1.00). No significant difference was observed in the 1 year follow-up outcomes, which were 91.4% (32/35 patients) in the Burch and 91.2% (73/80) in the hysterectomy groups. The results showed that there were no adverse effects on the 1 year follow-up outcomes or complications in patients who underwent a Burch colposuspension with an abdominal hysterectomy.

Comparative Study of Tension-free Vaginal Tape and Burch Colposuspension in the Surgical Management of Female Stress Urinary Incontinence / 대한산부인과학회잡지

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to compare the effectiveness, easiness, postoperative complications between tension-free vaginal tape (TVT) and Burch colposuspension (BC) in the surgical management of female genuine stress urinary incontinence. METHODS: A retrospective study of 77 cases with stress urinary incontinence at Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology and Urology, Pochon CHA University Medical College from January 2000 to December 2002, followed up more than 6 months. All of 77 cases were above grade 2 genuine stress urinary incontinence, 37 cases were performed tension-free vaginal tape, 40 cases were performed Burch colposuspension. RESULTS: Cure rate was 91.4% in the tension-free vaginal tape (TVT) group, 90% in the Burch colposuspension group. The mean operative time for TVT was 23.4 minutes and for Burch colposuspension was 47.2 minutes. The mean hospital stay in TVT was 1.8 days and in Burch colposuspension was 5.2 days. The incidence and severity of postoperative complication is similar in both groups. CONCLUSION: The cure rates of TVT were comparable with Burch colposuspension in the surgical management of female genuine stress urinary incontinence. And the incidence and severity of postoperative complication is similar in both groups. Moreover TVT is simple procedure more than Burch colposuspension.

Comparative Study of Tension-free Vaginal Tape and Burch Colposuspension in the Surgical Management of Female Stress Urinary Incontinence / 대한산부인과학회잡지

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to compare the effectiveness, easiness, postoperative complications between tension-free vaginal tape (TVT) and Burch colposuspension (BC) in the surgical management of female genuine stress urinary incontinence. METHODS: A retrospective study of 77 cases with stress urinary incontinence at Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology and Urology, Pochon CHA University Medical College from January 2000 to December 2002, followed up more than 6 months. All of 77 cases were above grade 2 genuine stress urinary incontinence, 37 cases were performed tension-free vaginal tape, 40 cases were performed Burch colposuspension. RESULTS: Cure rate was 91.4% in the tension-free vaginal tape (TVT) group, 90% in the Burch colposuspension group. The mean operative time for TVT was 23.4 minutes and for Burch colposuspension was 47.2 minutes. The mean hospital stay in TVT was 1.8 days and in Burch colposuspension was 5.2 days. The incidence and severity of postoperative complication is similar in both groups. CONCLUSION: The cure rates of TVT were comparable with Burch colposuspension in the surgical management of female genuine stress urinary incontinence. And the incidence and severity of postoperative complication is similar in both groups. Moreover TVT is simple procedure more than Burch colposuspension.

Comparison of Burch Colposuspension, Pubovaginal Sling Operation and Tension-Free Vaginal Tape for Surgical Treatment of Stress Urinary Incontinence In Women / 대한산부인과학회잡지

OBJECTIVE: The object of this study was to compare the cure rate and confirm the clinical efficacy of three most frequent surgical procedures for stress urinary incontinence (Burch colposuspension, pubovaginal sling operation, tension-free vaginal tape). MATERIALS AND METHODS: We collected datas from the records of ninety-one patients who were diagnosed as stress urinary incontinence from Jan. 1999 to May 2001. Burch colposuspension was performed by department of gynecology, Severance hospital in thirty-three patients, pubovaginal sling operation was performed by department of urology in twenty-eight patients, and tension-free vaginal tape was performed by department of urology in thirty-one patients. We investigated the characteristics of patients, preoperative urodynamic study results, cure rates and complication rates for the result, and compared them by x2-test. RESULTS: There were statistically no significant differences between the cure rate of each operation after 3, 6 month of operation but after 12 months of follow up, the cure rate of pubovaginal sling operation was significantly higher than that of Burch operation and tension-free vaginal tape. CONCLUSION: The cure rate of pubovaginal sling operation was significantly higher after 12 months of follow up after surgery. There was no significant difference between cure rates of Burch operation and tension- free vaginal tape. We propose randomized prospective study with larger population in the future.

Comparison between Extraperitoneal Laparoscopic Burch Colposuspension Using Mesh and Tacker and Open Burch Procedure / 대한비뇨기과학회지

PURPOSE: A Laparoscopic Burch colposuspension has rapidly become one of the primary surgical treatment options for genuine stress urinary incontinence (GSI). An extraperitoneal laparoscopic Burch procedure using polypropylene mesh and Tacker was compared with a open Burch procedure to evaluate the efficacy of this procedure. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A retrospective study of 61 consecutive cases diagnosed with GSI, and a subsequent followed up for 24 months or even longer (range: 24-40 months) were conducted. These evaluations were compared with 28 open Burch procedures during the same time period. All patients were assessed for their previous medical history, physical examination, cough stress test, transperineal ultrasonography, urethrocystoscopy, filling cystometries and urethral pressure profiles at both rest and strain. RESULTS: The overall success rate of the two methods was similar. The results showed that an extraperitoneal laparoscopic Burch operation reduced the duration of catheter drainage (1.4+/-0.8 days versus 3.6+/-1.2 days), hospital stay (2.2+/-1.1 days versus 7.8+/-1.5 days), and operation time (48.2+/-18.4min. versus 57.4+/-20.2min.) compared to the open Burch operation (p<0.05). However there were no significant differences in the complication rates. CONCLUSIONS: Extraperitoneal laparoscopic Burch colposuspension using a mesh and Tacker provides a durable resolution for GSI with low risk of conversion, short hospitalization, operation time and few complications. Further clinical assessment is necessary to evaluate its long-term feasibility.

Osteitis Pubis after Laparoscopic Burch Colposuspension Using Tacker(R) / 대한비뇨기과학회지

Osteitis pubis is a noninfectious, painful, inflammmatory condition affecting the periosteum, cartilage, and ligaments of the symphysis pubis. It has been associated with urologic and gynecologic procedures, pregnancy and rheumatologic disorders. Despite seven decades of speculation, its pathogenesis, diagnostic criteria, natural history and optimal therapy for osteitis pubis remain controversial. We had experienced two cases of osteitis pubis after laparoscopic Burch colposuspension using prolene mesh and Tacker(R). All cases of osteitis pubis were treated with conservative managements.

Comparison of Extraperitoneal Laparoscopic Versus Open Burch Colposuspension for Treatment of Stress Urinary Incontinence: Long Term Follow-up / 대한비뇨기과학회지

PURPOSE: Laparoscopic Burch colposuspension has been described as an alternative method to the surgical correction of stress urinary incontinence. We attempt to compare long-term results of laparoscopic and open Burch colposuspension in women with stress urinary incontinence. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed 51 consecutive cases of extra peritoneal laparoscopic (n=31) and open Burch colposuspension (n=20). Success rate was assessed by telephone interview and clinical data. RESULTS: Preoperative data of the two groups were not different statistically. The suc cess rate of laparoscopic group was 74.2% with a mean follow-up of 48.1 months and that of open Burch group was 80.0% with a mean follow-up of 43.1 months. On comparing extraperitoneal laparoscopic and open Burch procedure, laparoscopic group significantly required shorter operating time (110 minutes versus 138 minutes; p <0.05), shorter length of hospitalization (3.6 days versus 7.4 days; 0.01) and shorter catheter indwelling time (2.5 days versus 4.2 days; 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Extraperitoneal laparoscopic Burch colposuspension offers a less in vasive and effective approach to the surgical correction of stress urinary incontinence in terms of success rate, hospital stay and catheter indwelling time in properly selected patients.

Comparative Evaluation of Abdominal, Transvaginal and Laparoscopic Burch Colposuspension for Genuine Stress Incontinence / 대한비뇨기과학회지

PURPOSE: Burch colposuspension has been used for the treatment of stress urinary incontinence (SUI) with effectiveness. The purpose of this retrospective study was to compare the efficacy among abdominal, transvaginal and laparoscopic Burch colposuspension. We also compared the clinical course and complications after each procedure. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Sixty seven patients underwent Burch colposuspension were evaluated according to their approach methods. All patients were assessed for detailed history, physical examination, urodynamic study, transperineal ultrasonography, operative time, catheter indwelling period, hospital stays, success rate, and complications. RESULTS: The success rates of abdominal, transvaginal and laparoscopic Burch were 90, 86 and 76% respectively, at 26 months follow up. There was no significant complication except for a case of bladder injury in the laparoscopy group. Laparoscopic Burch operation had advantages of less invasive approach, less morbidity, shorter hospital stays and provided successful outcomes in patients with stress urinary incontinence. CONCLUSIONS: With these results, we could conclude that open, transvaginal or laparoscopic Burch operations were effective and safe for SUI with no significant differences of efficacy according to approach methods.

Laparoscopic Burch Colposuspension (Transperitoneal Approach) / 대한비뇨기과학회지

PURPOSE: The Burch bladder neck suspension is a effective treatment for stress urinary incontinence due to hypermobility. To assess the safety, effectiveness and potential benefits of the transperitoneal laparoscopic Burch colposuspension. MATERIALS AND METHOD: We assessed the short-term result of 15 patients who underwent a laparoscopic Burch colposuspension with transperitoneal approach. All patients had stress incontinence with bladder neck hypermobility and no cystocele and rectocele. The 14 patients had coexisting disorder(uterine myoma 11, ovarian cyst 2, carcinoma in situ 1), so concomitant operation was performed 14 cases(laparoscopic assisted vaginal hysterectomy 12, laparoscopic assisted ovarian cystectomy. RESULTS: In 15 patient who underwent the laparoscopic procedure, continent in 11(73%), improved in 1 (6%) and failed in 3(20%) with mean follow-up of 14 months (range 6-18). The mean operation time was 81 minutes(range 70-120), mean postoperative hospital stay was 4.8 days(range 3-7). CONCLUSIONS: Laparoscopic colposuspension with the transperitoneal approach is a reasonable alternative in treating stress urinary incontinence, especially when the patients have previous properitoneal or lower abdominal surgery or concomitant operation for coexisting disease. Early results are similar to those of open and needle suspension techniques, although longer follow-up is necessary to determine longterm efficiency.